---
title: "Will a New York State court rule grants the petitioners preliminary or permanent injunctive or annulment relief (other than a temporary restraining order) against the City's supplemental tax roll, its surcharge notices, or its imposition or collection of the pied-à-terre surcharge?"
canonical_url: https://betcrypto.now/events/will-a-new-york-state-court-rule-grants-the-petitioners-preliminary-or-permanent-injunctive-or-annulment-relief-other-than-a-temporary-restraining-order-against-the-citys-supplemental-tax-roll-its-surcharge-notices-or-its-impositio-ed5bcb5b
status: settled
trading_closes_at: 2026-09-30T18:04:16+00:00
settled_at: 2026-09-30T18:04:16+00:00
total_volume_usd: 4104.67
venues: ["Kalshi"]
categories: ["Politics"]
prices_as_of: 2026-11-07T23:00:29+00:00
publisher: BetCrypto
data_api: https://betcrypto.now/api/v1/events/will-a-new-york-state-court-rule-grants-the-petitioners-preliminary-or-permanent-injunctive-or-annulment-relief-other-than-a-temporary-restraining-order-against-the-citys-supplemental-tax-roll-its-surcharge-notices-or-its-impositio-ed5bcb5b
---

# Will a New York State court rule grants the petitioners preliminary or permanent injunctive or annulment relief (other than a temporary restraining order) against the City's supplemental tax roll, its surcharge notices, or its imposition or collection of the pied-à-terre surcharge?

Settled · $4,105 traded · listed on Kalshi

## Result

**Yes** won. Settled 2026-09-30.

## About

If a New York State court grants the petitioners preliminary or permanent injunctive or annulment relief (other than a temporary restraining order) against the City's supplemental tax roll, its surcharge notices, or its imposition or collection of the pied-à-terre surcharge in O'Brien v. City of New York, or any appeal thereof before Jan 1, 2027, then the market resolves to Yes.

This market resolves on a written court ruling in O'Brien v. City of New York, the Article 78 proceeding brought in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Richmond County by Rachel O'Brien, Carmine Morano and Simon Hedley against Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Finance Commissioner Richard Lee over the rollout of the non-primary residence (pied-à-terre) surcharge. Rulings in any appeal of that proceeding also count.

The ruling must:

Be issued by a New York State court in O'Brien v. City of New York, or any appeal thereof
Address the specific matter described in the judgment
Be issued through a written order, opinion, judgment, or decision

Relief on any one of the three heads is enough, and partial relief counts. An order that annuls or enjoins the supplemental tax roll, the surcharge notices, or the imposition or collection of the surcharge resolves this market to YES.

The following do NOT satisfy the Payout Criterion:

Oral rulings from the bench unless reduced to a written order
Tentative rulings that are not made final
Draft opinions that leak but are not officially issued
Settlements or voluntary dismissals
Administrative or scheduling orders
Orders to show cause
Minute orders that do not address the substantive issue in the judgment

The following also do NOT count, because they grant no injunctive or annulment relief:

The temporary restraining order issued August 10, 2026, or any later temporary restraining order
An order granting, confirming, vacating or dissolving a stay
Denial of a motion to dismiss or of any other dispositive motion
Voluntary action by the City, such as withdrawing notices, removing the tax roll, or extending a deadline

For clarity:

If the case is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, that counts as a ruling only if the judgment refers to jurisdiction
Sua sponte rulings count if they match the judgment
Per curiam opinions and summary orders count as rulings
If multiple judges issue separate opinions, the majority/plurality opinion controls
A ruling in a separate proceeding that has not been consolidated into this one does not count
If no qualifying ruling is issued after Issuance and before Jan 1, 2027, this market resolves to NO

_From Kalshi's listing._

## Open on a venue

- [Kalshi](https://betcrypto.now/go/e/311792?via=md)

---

Probability is the cross-venue consensus (book midpoints, 0–100%). Venue columns are what buying costs there (the ask). Prices move constantly; re-check at the canonical URL or the [JSON API](https://betcrypto.now/api/v1/events/will-a-new-york-state-court-rule-grants-the-petitioners-preliminary-or-permanent-injunctive-or-annulment-relief-other-than-a-temporary-restraining-order-against-the-citys-supplemental-tax-roll-its-surcharge-notices-or-its-impositio-ed5bcb5b).

BetCrypto is an odds-comparison and information service. It accepts no wagers and gives no betting or financial advice; prediction-market availability depends on where you live.